How Physicians Lost Credibility and Why it Matters: 1

Contrary to what most of you might believe, physicians had pretty shitty credibility for most of recorded history. While they were a few “superstars” attached to some famous king or feudal lord- the vast majority were seen as worse than midwifes, witches and traditional medicine men.

The two main reasons behind this poor public image were-

1. They could not do much to help their patients- modern surgery started in the 1890s, and modern medicine came into its own only after the mid-1930s.

2. Prior to the early 1900s, their understanding of physiology and pathology was so poor that they frequently hurt more people than they helped.

Modern medicine is therefore a relatively recent concept- about 60 odd years old. I would consider the period from 1950-2000 as the golden age of being a doctor- in terms of respectability and credibility. It began with antibiotics, advanced surgical techniques, useful drugs and ended with aging baby boomers, google and web 2.0.

So why and where did things go so wrong?

A. The average age of the patient and the type of diseases treated by physicians has changed over the years. In the early part of the golden age, the majority of diseases were acute to subacute (infections, accidents, injuries) because the average age of the population was low. Most treatments resulted in complete cures and satisfied patients.

Today the average patient is far older, has chronic diseases and is far less likely to be completely cured. Modern medicine is still pretty shitty at treating chronic diseases with some exceptions (high blood pressure, auto-immune diseases).

B. Doctors and surgeons have already lost a huge amount of credibility by acting in their own financial interests rather than for their patient. The amount of corruption in areas ranging from prescribing questionable new medications, accepting bribes from pharma, directing patients to use their testing facilities, performing useless or harmful surgical procedures has reached unthinkable levels.

In a previous era, such scams could be easily hidden because person-to-person communication was limited by available technology. Today every publicly available instance of misconduct gets circulated on the interwebs and is archived for posterity. Access to such real information has been corroding the image of physicians for the last 15 odd years- though the process has accelerated in the last decade for obvious reasons.

C. A combination of factors from medical tourism, information on the interwebs, patronizing attitude of physicians plus their sparse face-to-face time have created a situation where a significant percentage of the population now sees physicians as rich, black-mailing scam artists who use a guild system to extract money from people without providing good value for money.

Physicians for better or worse are the face of the health care system and will therefore also bear the culpability for mal-actions of hospital administrators, insurance companies and pharma.Their principal threat of job action- aka letting sick people die is not going to help them if they do it on a large scale. Nobody like a murderer who is also a black-mailer, even if they have MD after their name.

Did I mention that well-trained doctors from English speaking countries could be used to replace them? Politicians and bureaucrats will side with physician guilds only if it does not affect their grasp on power and survival.

In the next part I will talk about the consequences and effects of this credibility loss on physicians, the nature of medical practice and society at large.


  1. May 19, 2011 at 10:13 am

    It always struck me as strange the way pundits talk of doctors as though they are a fixed natural resource, like gold, of which there’s only a limited amount and there can never be more.

    I don’t understand why we don’t train a bajillion doctors by government fiat. After the first crop of students is finished, we could even have them teach themselves. We could saturate the market with doctors. There is nothing stopping it but stupid policy.

  2. May 21, 2011 at 10:28 am

    Hiya Analingus Diablo,

    Just remember an apple a day (and no health insurance) keeps the doctor away…..

    Rock On!

    Stoner With a Boner

  1. May 22, 2011 at 1:15 am
  2. December 6, 2013 at 8:52 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: