Home > Critical Thinking, Current Affairs, Dystopia, Musings, Philosophy sans Sophistry, Reason, Secular Religions, Skepticism, Technology > My Thoughts on the “Google Memo” and James Damore: Aug 9, 2017

My Thoughts on the “Google Memo” and James Damore: Aug 9, 2017

It appears that many of you want to hear my opinions about that now infamous “Google Memo” and its author- who has now been identified as James Damore. Well.. I had considered writing about this issue a couple of days ago, but thought it was best to wait until the guy at the center of this latest culture war controversy represented himself though an interview or two and maybe a detailed blog post. As it stands today, he seems to have given interviews to two people in what many would consider the ‘alt-right’.

In my opinion, who he gives an interview to at this time is not particularly relevant- since the Mass Media and SJWs of all persuasions are going out of their way to demonize and shut him out. This is not to say that I agree with every single word in his memo. However, the right to free speech (which I strongly support) is more important than the right of SJWs and other morons to feel “safe” from speech which they might find “offensive”. As long-time readers of my blog know, I am not fond of SJWs or the underlying motivations of their behavior.

As I have said in previous posts, SJW-ism is largely driven by the desire to show moral superiority (and perhaps make a quick buck) under neoliberalism. The current “intellectual” underpinnings of the slowly imploding neoliberal order do not allow real large-scale social problems to be addressed, and therefore activists and scammers spend their energy at promoting really small-scale causes such as transgender rights and the right for muslim women to wear a hijab while simultaneously ignoring endemic poverty, joblessness and overall misery seen in western neoliberal countries- especially the USA.

To put it another way, SJWs and their boosters in Mass Media are more interested in trying to make you feel ashamed about some video game you enjoy than push for universal healthcare. They would rather spend their efforts on trying to make you say that certain women comedians are talented and “beautiful” than lead a campaign for fully tax-funded university education. It is also no secret that many supposedly “liberal” TV personalities who pretend to care about social issues are just scammers making money out of misdirected outrage that is safe for their corporate backers.

So now you know where I stand on the issue of free speech, SJWs and Corporate Mass Media. But what about the actual contents of that memo or James Damore? Well.. this is the part that some of you might not like, because what I think about both of them is a bit more nuanced than my views on SJWs and Corporate Mass Media.

Firstly, the basic idea proposed in that memo- namely that women and men’s brains are not “wired” the same way is essentially correct. Now this does not mean that there is no overlap between the “wiring” of the two groups. In fact, there is far more overlap than many would be willing to accept. Having said that, you can make the claim that women as a group will perform better at some tasks than men as a group and vice versa.

This does not however translate into differences in gross intelligence or other large-scale abilities. As many of you know, women now make up almost half of doctors, lawyers and (in many countries) engineers and they seem to do as well as their male counterparts in these vocations. You might also recall that even 50 years, it was rare for women to be admitted in these field because of their supposed lack of intellectual ability. So clearly, all the beliefs which kept women out of intellectually demanding fields in previous eras were wrong.

Furthermore, psychological studies (which is largely made up bullshit) was once used as a justification to treat non-whites as subhuman. Today we are largely accept the idea that asians (both east- and south-) are very good at math and other STEM subjects and account for a disproportionate number of employees of technology heavy corporations and institutions. However as late as the 1960s, many prominent white scientists still believed that Asians were “low IQ” without any worthwhile ability for scientific or original thinking. How the tables have turned now..

And this brings me to what I think about the most significant, but overlooked, part of that memo. Though the document has been blasted for being overtly sexist, it is more about the corporate and office culture at Google in particular and corporate america in general. The guy is complaining about how the managerial and HR types at Google has basically stopped listening to opinions which diverge ever so slightly from their fashionable and “naturally correct” consensus. He is describing an organisation where the loudest and most manipulative faddists carry the day.

In short, he is describing an organisational culture which has more in common with royal courts, politburos and other large corporations that are dominated by clever and sociopathic power seekers than those who make the system function properly. I, for one, am not surprised that a large and unwieldy corporation such as Google has now more in common with other corporations and institutions with a similar head count and complex hierarchies than what it was a decade ago.

The fact that institutional bias at Google seems to be based in one fashionable type interpretation of the social “sciences” is just a quirk of the times we live in. Some of you might recall that many large corporations of yesteryears- such as Kodak, IBM, HP, Ford, GM, Merck too used have their own and equally well-known institutional biases based in conservative values or whatever corporate bullshit was fashionable at that moment. In fact, I wrote about inevitable emergence of such dysfunction in large institutions about six years ago.

Anyway, to summarize this post- what James Damore wrote in that memo has more to do with emergent dysfunction in large impersonal institutions than sexism. I would go far as to say that there is little, if any, sexism in that document. The very fact that he is being attacked for the basically nonexistent sexism in his memo says a lot about our contemporary media culture and society. Also, it says a lot about where Google is going.. or not going.

Might write more about this story depending on comments and future developments.

What do you think? Comments?

  1. P Ray
    August 9, 2017 at 6:26 pm

    They were looking for somebody to dare stick their neck out, and Mr. Damore rose to the goading.

    SJW are the type of people that harp about their difficulty in life while ignoring the huge issues … so, “the personal is political”, and they’re “playing Oppression Olympics to win”.

    There is a Chinese saying, “kill the chicken to scare the monkey”, Mr. Damore was to be made an object lesson.

    Even Sundar Pichai is afraid of these queen bees causing trouble for the organisation unless sated with Damore’s firing. That’s why he “cancelled my family vacation to deal with this urgent issue, that does not follow our Code of Conduct”.

    Some years earlier when Googlers I personally knew were scared to show their faces in a Youtube video set to the music of Harlem Shake, I knew something was wrong in Pyrmont, Sydney … but didn’t expect that the infection was company-wide.

    Looks like for some corporations, “High School Never Ends”.

    • Libertarians are superhumans
      August 10, 2017 at 12:16 am

      LOL, you do realise that the author of this blog is a SJW? The reason he does not consider himself an SJW is because he is not concerned about social justice for trannies, gays, women, obese people, and other SJ pet groups. However, he very much supports the race-obsessed social justice and class-warfare. He is a race-baiting Black-LIEs-Matter supporting SJW Bolshevist indeed.

    • P Ray
      August 10, 2017 at 2:12 am

      Urs Holzle (According to Bruce Reid, in 2004 Hölzle told Reid that his opinions and ideas were “obsolete” and “too old to matter,” that he was “slow,” “fuzzy,” “sluggish,” and “lethargic,” and that he did not “display a sense of urgency” and “lack[ed] energy.”) … has started policing his Wikipedia page to ensure that his part in the firing of Bruce Reid, 9 days before Google’s IPO in 2004 … doesn’t come to light.

      Google really is full of SJWs.

  2. August 10, 2017 at 9:27 am

    You really should come visit my website and comment:

    http://www.xtrabeing.wordpress.com

    You want a comment? I’ll give you a few, like em or not.

    You’re wrong about cunts. Aka bitches, twats, the inferior sex. I was in computer science, the most technogical of sciences and I saw how poorly they perform. They can parrot engineers’ equations like a robot, BUT THEY CANNOT DESIGN NEW THINGS. They are pure tokens. So there’s your first error.

    Your implicit pining-for free education is a canard and stupid. Someday I’m going to be a famous writer: if I gave my works out for free, aside from the vast profit-loss, do you think anyone would appreciate them? Subsidized education is appreciated as much as free water. If you really want it, like John Boehner or Henry Kissinger or a million others, you’ll get your higher education chops. Otherwise, fuck you and go work for the Golden Arches.

    Your comments about corporations — which I plan on running — are not bad. However you fail to ask yourself the question: IS THERE MAYBE A GOOD REASON GOOGLE AND OTHER CORPS TURN INTO THEIR ORGANIZATIONAL LATER-STAGE FORMS? Have they become idiots … or are they molting like caterpillars into their proper butterfly forms?

    Yours,

    Anxiously awaiting your counter-replies,

    X.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: